N.º 69 (2024): Mayo-agosto
Artículos

Aristotle’s Criticism of the Soul’s Self-Motion in DA I

PDF (English)
  • Liliana Carolina Sánchez Castro
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21555/top.v690.2624

Publicado 2024-04-04

Palavras-chave

Como Citar

Sánchez Castro, L. C. (2024). Aristotle’s Criticism of the Soul’s Self-Motion in DA I. Tópicos, Revista De Filosofía, (69), 11–29. https://doi.org/10.21555/top.v690.2624

Direitos de Autor (c) 2024 Tópicos, Revista de Filosofía

Creative Commons License

Este trabalho encontra-se publicado com a Licença Internacional Creative Commons Atribuição-NãoComercial-SemDerivações 4.0.

Downloads

Não há dados estatísticos.

Altmetrics

Citas

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Resumo

In this paper, I examine Aristotle’s position on the theory of the soul as a self-moving entity in the light of a less negative conception of his discussion with his predecessors. For this purpose, I discuss the hypothesis according to which Aristotle is producing the concepts necessary for his own research through a critique of Plato’s claims. I show that, more than a criticism, what we are witnessing is a process of conceptual appropriation where Aristotle filters an opinion to make a better use of it. I support my argument by showing how Aristotle’s exegetical device works and how it could be connected to his own definitional procedures in De Anima’s book II.

PDF (English)

Referências

  1. Aristotle. (1907). De Anima. R. D. Hicks (trans.). Cambridge University Press.
  2. Aristotle. (1953) Metaphysica. D. Ross (ed.). Clarendon Press.
  3. Aristotle. (1966). De l’âme. A. Jannone & E. Barbotin (trans.). Les Belles Lettres.
  4. Aristotle. (1967a). De Anima. D. Ross (ed.). Clarendon Press.
  5. Aristotle. (1967b). Topiques. Livres I-IV. J. Brunschwig (trans.). Les Belles Lettres.
  6. Aristotle. (1968). De Anima. Books II and III (with Passages from Book I). D. W. Hamlyn (trans.). Clarendon Press.
  7. Aristotle. (1988). Acerca del alma. T. Calvo (trans.). Gredos.
  8. Aristotle. (1991). On the Soul. In The Complete Works of Aristotle. (pp. 1-64). J. Barnes (ed.). J. A. Smith (trans.). Princeton University Press.
  9. Aristotle. (1993). De l’âme. R. Bodéüs (trans.). Flammarion.
  10. Aristotle. (2010). Acerca del alma. M. Boeri (trans.). Colihue.
  11. Aristotle. (2016). De Anima. C. Shields (trans.). Clarendon Press.
  12. Aristotle. (2017). Über die Seele – De Anima. K. Corcilius (trans.). Feliz Meiner.
  13. Aristotle. (2021). Rhétorique. Livre I. M. Dufour (trans.). Les Belles Lettres.
  14. Baltussen, H. (1996). A ‘Dialectical’ Argument in De Anima A 4: On Aristotle’s Use of Topoi in Systematic Contexts. In K. Algra, P. van der Horst, & K. Runia (eds.), Polyhistor: Studies in the History and Historiography of Ancient Philosophy. (pp. 333-343). Brill.
  15. Boeri, M. (2010). Introducción. In Aristotle, Acerca del alma. (pp. xiii-ccxxxiv). Colihue.
  16. Boeri, M. (2018). Plato and Aristotle on What Is Common to Soul and Body. Some Remarks on a Complicated Issue. In M. Boeri, Y. Y. Kanayama, & J. Mittelmann (eds.), Soul and Mind in Greek Thought: Psychological Issues in Plato and Aristotle. (pp. 153-176). Springer.
  17. Bolton, R. (1994). The Epistemological Basis of Aristotelian Dialectic. In M. Sim (ed.), From Puzzles to Principles: Essays on Aristotle’s Dialectic. (pp. 57-106). Lexington Books.
  18. Carter, J. (2018). Does the Soul Weave? Reconsidering De Anima I.4, 408a29-b18. Phronesis 63(1), 25-63. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/15685284-12341341.
  19. Carter, J. (2019). Aristotle on Earlier Greek Psychology: The Science of Soul. Cambridge University Press.
  20. Cherniss, H. (1935). Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Philosophy. The John Hopkins Press.
  21. Cherniss, H. (1944). Aristotle’s Criticism of Plato and the Academy. I. The John Hopkins Press.
  22. King, C. G. (2021). Δόξαι and the Tools of Dialectic in De Anima I.1-3. In P. Gregoric & J. Fink (eds.), Encounters with Aristotelian Philosophy of Mind. (pp. 15-42). Routledge
  23. Menn, S. (2002). Aristotle’s Definition of Soul and the Program of the De Anima. In D. Sedley (ed.), Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy. Volume XXII. (pp. 83-129). Oxford University Press.
  24. Plato. (1901). Opera. II. Tetralogias III-IV. J. Burnet (ed.). Clarendon Press.
  25. Plato. (1997a). Complete Works. J. Cooper (ed.). Hackett.
  26. Plato. (1997b). Phaedrus. In Plato, Complete Works. (pp. 506-556). J. Cooper (ed.). A. Nehamas & P. Woodruff (trans.). Hackett.
  27. Polansky, R. (2007). Aristotle’s De Anima. Cambridge University Press.
  28. Rapp, C. (2018). Aporia and Dialectical Method in Aristotle. In G. Karamanolis & V. Politis (eds.), The Aporetic Tradition in Ancient Philosophy. (pp. 112-136). Cambridge University Press.
  29. Sánchez Castro, L. C. (2016). Traditio Animae: la recepción aristotélica de las teorías presocráticas del alma. Universidad Nacional de Colombia.
  30. Viano, C. (1996). La doxographie du De Anima (I, 2-5) ou le contre-modèle de l’âme. In C. Viano, Corps et âme. Études sur le De Anima. (pp. 51-80). Vrin.
  31. Witt, C. (1992). Dialectic, Motion, and Perception: De Anima, Book I. In M. Nussbaum & A. Oksenberg (eds.), Essays on Aristotle’s De Anima. (pp. 169-183). Clarendon Press.