Número 20 - 2001
Articles

Some Remarks on Aristotle’s discussion with the Eleatics in Physics I

PDF (Español (España))
  • Gabriela Rossi
Gabriela Rossi
Universidad de Navarra
DOI: https://doi.org/10.21555/top.v20i1.325

Published 2013-11-28

Keywords

How to Cite

Rossi, G. (2013). Some Remarks on Aristotle’s discussion with the Eleatics in Physics I. Tópicos, Revista De Filosofía, 20(1), 137–159. https://doi.org/10.21555/top.v20i1.325
Copyright Notice

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Altmetrics

Citas

Crossref
Scopus
Google Scholar
Europe PMC

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to illustrate the role of some peculiar elements of Aristotle's dialectical development —namely, those emerging in the Sophistical Refutations (SE)— in the analysis and discussion of the Eleatic thesis in Physics I, 2-3. The paper adresses some of Aristotle's preliminary thoughts (Phys. I, 2) (which are read as methodological considerations), and some remarks against Melissus' argument (Phys. I, 3), in order to find connections between such claims and passages of SE, as well as the Topics.

PDF (Español (España))

References

  1. Aristóteles. (1958). Topica et Sophistici Elenchi. W. D. Ross (ed.) Oxford.
  2. ____ (1989). Physikvorlesung. H. Wagner (trad.) Berlín.
  3. ____ (1993). Física. Libros I y II. M. D. Boeri (trad.) Buenos Aires.
  4. ____ (1995). Les réfutations sophistiques. L. A. Dorion (trad.) Paris.
  5. ____ (1996). Topik. O. Primavesi (trad.) München.
  6. Bolton, R. (1991). Aristotle’s Method in Natural Science. En Aristotle’s Physics. A Collection ​of Essays. Oxford.
  7. ____ (1999). Dialectical Communities: From the One to the Many and Back. En From puzzles ​to principles? M. Sim (ed.) Lanham.
  8. Cherniss, H. (1935). La crítica aristotélica a la filosofía presocrática. México.
  9. Chichi, G. (1994). Tradición y aporte de Los Tópicos de Aristóteles: Análisis de su epílogo. ​En Synthesis, 1: 43-62.
  10. Düring, I. (1990). Aristóteles. Exposición e Interpretación de su Pensamiento. México.
  11. Evans, J. (1975). The codification of false refutations in Aristotle’s De Sophisticis Elenchis. ​En Proceedings of Cambridge Philosophy Society, 21.
  12. Gershenson, D., Greenberg, D. (1961). Melissus of Samos in a New Light: Aristotle’s Physics ​186a10-16. En Phronesis, 6: 1-9.
  13. ____ (1962). Aristotle Confronts the Eleatics: Two Arguments on ‘The One’. En Phronesis, ​7: 137-151.
  14. Hamblin, C. L. (1970). Fallacies. Virginia.
  15. Irwin, T. (1992). Aristotle’s First Principles. 2da ed. Oxford. Juan Filópono. In Aristotelis Physicorum libros tres priores commentaria. En Commentaria in ​Aristotelem Graeca. Vol. 16. H. Vitelli (ed.) Berlín.
  16. Kapp, E. (1942). Greek Foundatioin of traditional Logic. New York.
  17. Mansion, A. (1913). Introduction à la Physique Aristotélicienne. Louvain.
  18. Muller, R. (1985). Les mégariques. Fragments et témoignages. Paris.
  19. Owen, G. E. L. (1960). Logic and Metaphysics in Some Earlier Works of Aristotle. En ​Aristotle and Plato in the Mid-fourth Century. Götteborg.
  20. ____ (1961). Τίθέναι τὰ φαινόμενα. En Aristote et les problèmes de Méthode. ​S. Mansion (ed.) Louvain.
  21. Simplicio. (1882). In Aristotelis Physicorum libros quattuor priores commentaria. En ​Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca. Vol. 9. H. Diels (ed.) Berlín.
  22. Smith, R. (1993). Aristotle on the uses of dialectic. En Synthese, 96: 335-358.
  23. ____ (1999). Dialectic and Method in Aristotle. En From puzzles to principles? M. Sim (ed.) ​Lanham.
  24. Temistio. (1900). Aristotelis Physica Paraphrasis. En Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca. ​Vol. 5. H. Schenkl (ed.) Berlín.
  25. Wieland, W. (1962). Die Aristotelische Physik. Göttingen.